Unlike Makeup Morsels, I might fight you to TAKE this lipstick away…
Ok, it’s not that bad – and in fact, for some I suspect it might be really good. But I am VERY not sure about this color on me. Its in your face but I don’t think in a good way.
The new(ish) Kate x Rimmel lipsticks boast a variety of bold, saturated shades that are probably every lipstick-wearer’s dream. They’re creamy and easily opaque, and Kate Moss made ‘em by hand (no, really!). Well, at least she endorses them, so they’ve got to be cool, right?
The case is actually quite sleek and attractive, jet black with Kate’s ‘signature’ on the side written in red, with not much else. Alongside my other higher-end lippies, it fits right in.
The shade I selected was 06, a bright deep pink that leans more warm than cool. I envisioned myself wearing this and little else, much like the J Crew models (god they make that look good!). However, because this shade is SO opaque, it actually looks a little….I dunno, fake somehow? As if wearing a screaming pink lipstick isn’t fake enough, right?
Sunlight
Flash
Natural light
Aside from perhaps the poor shade choice, I also find this lipstick to highlight any imperfections on the lips (so be sure to prep very carefully), and while it’s creamy, it’s not particularly moisturizing so I would opt to apply a thin layer of balm beforehand if you have drier lips. It’s not terribly problematic, but I’ve worn some lipsticks just as is so it’s something to note. Also, the scent is typical Rimmel, which is to say – sort of cinnamon-y? I don’t know what that scent is but I’m not a huge fan. It’s not overpowering or noticeable once worn, but it’s kinda weird.
Overall I’d probably pick up another shade of these as they’re fairly inexpensive (mine was on sale for around $5.79 but they’re probably around $8CAD full price), they have a fun shade range, and they do apply and wear well. If you’re easing your way into wearing a ‘trendy’ lip color, this is a good way to go.
Do you think this is too bright for me? What shade of lipstick do you have a hard time wearing?
#1 by callitbeautyblog on August 1, 2012 - 10:17 pm
Girl, you’re crazy! This looks absolutely gorgeous on you!
THAT SAID… Wearing and pulling off bright, in-your-face lippies is all dependent on the wearer’s comfort. If you don’t feel comfortable wearing that shade, it will look all sorts of wrong to you (perhaps this is why it looks “fake” to you?) even though to everyone else, it looks fab. Still, shades like these are definitely not meant to look natural, so I think fake is good? :p
#2 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:39 pm
Hahaha yes, I hear what you’re saying Dani! I think the problem isn’t the color or brightness though (I’ve been taking a cue from you brave bandits!)…there is something about the formula that lays on the lips strangely I think. I think I can make it work if I apply it just so – but it’s just not an ideal formula
Sent from my iPhone
#3 by makeupmorsels on August 1, 2012 - 10:25 pm
Oh no! That bad? Well no fighting needed, I will gladly spirit this away from you
I can’t say if it’s too bright or not without seeing a full face shot, but if you don’t feel comfortable wearing the color, that’s really all that matters. Think you might try any of the other shades?
#4 by makeupmorsels on August 1, 2012 - 10:26 pm
*whoops, I meant to say do you have any other shades in mind? Cuz you answered the first one. And I know that hahahah.
Also, I’m with Dani. Based on the lip swatch, I like what I see!
#5 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:43 pm
LOL thanks hun! And no, no other shades in mind right now!
Sent from my iPhone
#6 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:42 pm
I’m not sure, MM. It’s not the brightness exactly, but the formula that bugs me and makes me feel like this is too obvious. But you’re right, if you don’t rock it with confidence, regardless, it’s not going to work.
Sent from my iPhone
#7 by BeautyReflections (@BeautyReflectTS) on August 1, 2012 - 10:41 pm
I’m with the other two bandits-I love it! It’s so bright and fun! Maybe blot it down a bit so you feel more comfy wearing it?
I have the Kate nude one and I just bought the gunmetal one to. I like them! The nude one is great for me-I have a hard time finding a nude lipstick that works.
#8 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:45 pm
Awesome Tracy! I have yet to find a good nude also.
I do find that this applied somewhat softly does work better. I’m glad everyone likes it so much! Maybe I’m being needlessly self-conscious.
Sent from my iPhone
#9 by Larie on August 1, 2012 - 10:45 pm
Fourth bandit opinion: KEEP IT, GIRL. It looks good! Based on what I can see, it looks fab. Paired with barely there blush and thick winged liner? YES.
#10 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:47 pm
That IS one of my face ways to wear bright lippies, Larie! Must attempt again – you Bandits kinda know what you’re talking about, after all!
Sent from my iPhone
#11 by Liz (@Reductionista) on August 1, 2012 - 11:26 pm
Honorary bandit here – I say it’s good, too. If you can wear bright yellow shadows, you can totally pull this off. I have a bright fuchsia L’Oreal that I fear was a terrible mistake but I kept it with hopes of future bravery. You’re much braver than I am with colours so revel in it.
#12 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:49 pm
Haha thank you Liz! You’re vote of confidence helps! I’m going to give this another go, because it’s not the shade I dislike – I just need to figure out how to wear it in a way I feel comfortable, I guess!
Sent from my iPhone
#13 by judit1661 on August 2, 2012 - 12:23 am
I say keep it, it’s gorge! But along with everyone else if you are not comfortable wearing it, well then you know what will happen to it? It will wind up at the bottom of the pile and you will come across it in a few years and wonder hmmm why didn’t I wear this, it looks great! I have the 08 and I really love it, I find myself reaching for it way more than I thought I would.
You’ll have to keep us posted on your decision of the bright pink lippie!
Xoxo
#14 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:54 pm
LOL will do Judi! I know it’s all about attitude, so I just have to throw this on and work it!!
Sent from my iPhone
#15 by Amy on August 2, 2012 - 12:39 am
I must agree with everyone else––it looks gorgeous from the pics, but makeup should never be stressful to wear! You can always wear it as a sheer stain over moisturized lips if wearing it full strength is too much, but I think it looks lovely as-is!
#16 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:55 pm
You gals are all so smart and sweet, I can’t stand it! I will try this as a stain too Amy, good suggestion – see if that takes the ‘fake’ away
Sent from my iPhone
#17 by Christine Brigid on August 2, 2012 - 2:25 am
I agree with the crowd– looks amazing on you. BUT, I also understand what you are saying about the flatness of the lipstick making it look sort of like it sits on top of your lips… I have two Kate Rimmel’s– 01 in Red, and 12(?) an orange leaning coral. The red is great, but the coral is SO weirdly bold. I’m not sure about it at all.
#18 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 6:58 pm
Ahhh thank you Christine!! You totally know what I mean! It’s not the shade but the actual lipstick itself! It’s weird, no? I can almost make it work, but I wonder if it’s worth the effort!
Sent from my iPhone
#19 by Becca @ The Beauty Sample on August 2, 2012 - 6:23 am
I actually love how this looks on you–you’re crazy!
#20 by Latoya on August 2, 2012 - 6:41 am
LOL Concise and to the point, Becca
I’m glad everyone seems to enjoy it – I’ll have to give it a second chance 
Sent from my iPhone
#21 by Tati D. on August 2, 2012 - 2:05 pm
I don’t know, it looks pretty good on you!
#22 by Latoya on August 3, 2012 - 8:43 am
Aw, thanks Tati! I think its just a combo of not being totally used to wearing brights, and a slightly strange formula!
Sent from my iPhone
#23 by Sylvie (@alipstickaday) on August 3, 2012 - 2:18 am
I think it’s a keeper? It looks good on you!
#24 by Latoya on August 5, 2012 - 3:44 pm
Thanks Sylvie!! I think I’m just not fully used to bright lip colors yet, though I’m working on it!! And for $5 I can’t complain too much, right?
#25 by Eugenia on August 3, 2012 - 5:31 pm
From your swatches, Toya, I would never have believed that this shade is problematic at all! Plus, it looks stunning on you! I picked this up months ago, and never even wore it, let alone swatched it; what is it with me and these uber-bright hues? I’m forever going after shades like this, but with my colouring I always feel that I come off looking kind of tacky. Maybe when I return from my holidays, I’ll give this a shot – a tan always makes something this vivid looks good, am I right?!
#26 by Latoya on August 7, 2012 - 7:04 pm
LOL In many ways, yes!!
Though I sometimes think that deeper/more olive skin tones look best on more subtle, glowing shades. That isn’t to say we can’t wear these tones, and rock them, but I just think more muted shades are *better*. Anyway, brights can be a fun way to switch it up and I think that like everyone has said, if you wear it with confidence then it’s bound to look great!
Sent from my iPhone